cover_photo

Old Ben's Jedi Punishment Appeal

By, goth, posted 1 week ago

1 week ago - edited

# nS6Tn-hA-_EmDApD

Steam & In-game Name: STEAM_0:1:563680323 / Old Ben

What was your punishment?: Unbecoming Behaviour of a Jedi ( Strike + Demotion )

Reason for Punishment: Blowing up a subjugator as well as apparently disobeying GC / Disregarding orders

Battalion and Person who issued punishment: Jedi Council

Why you believe the punishment is unjustified: Alright first things first the blowing up of a subjugator was done through roleplay and I had the GMs permission to do so, so I went through with it and it gave a different outcome to what should've happened which is what events should be like, player and story driven cause not all things go to the exact plan as it would make events stale and not fun at all and now for the second reason I was not disregarding orders at all, as a temple guard I insisted to go with Shaak Ti as a Temple Guard's duty is to protect the council. After I asked one or two times I then went to the otherside where I was originally supposed to be designated for, I just wanted to ask Shaak Ti and let her know that as a Temple Guard it is my duty. Another example that was given was me telling Shaak Ti and another trooper to move out the way as they were interfering with a prisoner that I was handling with shock and apparently that was a reason for me to be punished for doing my duties. I would also like to make it clear that I only said ''move out the way'' and someone else said ''hes a temple guard he has jurisdication over this'' I was the one that did NOT say that. Overall I've been treated unfairly within the Jedi Order for some time and I just haven't decided to take action until now since the first time I tried to do something about it, it instantly got denied so I just said meh whatever happens happens and I'll prove them wrong. Also to be clear, this did not go againsr GC’s orders, it was never mentioned nor said out loud, I also dont see why we were using a subjugator to infiltrate a planet as that isnt how the Republic would act, they’d instead use a republic issued ship. This was brought up in the briefing by multiple saying that it wouldn’t make any sense to use a subjugator just to infiltrate a planet, if anything it should’ve been destroyed in combat or decommissioned cause its a subjugator for crying out loud

Evidence to back up your case (Highly Adviced): I would like to say that there is no evidence for either side to confirm what actually happened to justify the cause meaning that I was punished on speculation and treated like I meant to do what I did to hurt the order rather than making a fun RP scenario which proved truthfully after.

Current:
Temple Guard Lead

Nahdar Vebb
Senate Commando


Titles:

Former Aayla Secura
Former Second 332nd Ahsoka Tano

024d30c0-7194-4694-90e7-2294df10f41c.png

0


1 week ago - edited

# YNgT1O14PERcA7u1

+support
If things did truly did happen the way you state, I do not believe this should have resulted in punishment or at least not a strike. As a GM I would have found this nice and funny. I will say that if you blowing the ship up went directly against GCs orders I can see grounds for punishment but from this testimony it doesn't appear you did.

Obviously there is always two sides to a story and without evidence I don't really know if this appeal will be accepted but best of luck.

CURRENT
212th Commander Cody
Senior Forums Admin
Admin
Quest Lead

FORMER
MC 1LT 212th RM Bear
212th 2ABL
21st SSGT KUE

Resurrector of Ghost Company
-might be the best Cody of all time-
GL REFUGE

0

1 week ago

# UgvJRVuiJe13oLTl

-1

Just because you have permission to do something from a GM, doesn't mean it should be done. That ship was meant to be used during the mission, destroying it is against orders, in my opinion.

The way I see it, it's a "I mean, you can do it but should you?" situation. Yes, you had permission from the GM but that doesn't mean you should do it.

Commander Cody 4/27/24-7/7/24

Longest Reigning Padawan III 3/8/24-7/7/24

Obi-Wan Kenobi 9/28/24-12/29/24

First High Jedi 12/29/24-4/26/25

Yoda 4/26/25-12/4/25

"I WILL FIST THE CHANCELLOR TO H***!"

0

6 days ago

# 1XnQHEvPxIjgXCDF

I'm With what Dessel Said, I tell people they can do stuff all the Time for RP, But it could have repercussions in RP or out of RP especially when going against GC etc

Current GM Coordinator
Current 41st Vice Commander


Former:
Naval Officer
Retired 41st Commander Gree
Shock Vice Commander Thorn

Once a 41st always a 41st.


Have a Good Rest my Fallen Brethren.


f399f7cc-513c-4aaf-a0d9-ea009933e231.jpg

0

5 days ago

# JoZlJ1GpaT52thMX

=-=-= ACCEPTED =-=-=

Your strike and demotion will be removed.

Current:

MOTO Mace Windu

Assistant Support Lead

Former

Jedi Shadow Advisor Quinlan Vos

212th Regimental Medic

Navy Officer

104th Officer

212th NCO

Jedi Master Kit Fisto

Medical Officer

0

Join this community to post or comment